Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Tuesday Tropes: The Collapsing Lair


After all they've been through, our heroes have defeated the baddie. Time to celebrate, right? Unfortunately, the villain's pad hasn't been renovated in centuries, and for some odd reason, killing off the bad guy resonates throughout the entire structure. No time to party. They have to run for it, before the ceiling crashes on their heads!

The Collapsing Lair - The demise of a villain's base of operations after their defeat, an event that results after accomplishing a goal in a structurally unsound place (usually an ancient tomb or treasure room). Often used as a grand finale or as an easy way to obliterate any remaining minions or evidence of the villain's existence.


On rare occasions, the villain may be alive while the place falls down, and ends up "going down with the ship," so to speak. Having a herd of unicorns trampling by your front door is certainly of no help.

I hope Haggard's insurance covers unicorn stampedes.

At other times, a Collapsing Lair may be caused by a booby trap or a switch, meant to activate a snare that will bury any who trespasses.

Run, Indy, run!

Now hold on a second - how come all these ancient structures get to have all the fun? Why not shake things up a little by having the lair be a starship, collapsing in a great ball of fiery glory or something?

Oh, right ... they've done that ...

This is a fun trope to apply if there is a sound reason for it, otherwise it looks and reads tacky when it's thrown in without foreshadowing it, or it's there for no other reason than to pour salt into the wound.

And thanks for visiting my laire; mind your heads on the way out ...

What are your favorite Collapsing Lair scenes? Which ones made you groan? Have you ever thought of using this trope, or have you? 

I'm David, and goodbye, Beni ...

27 comments:

  1. Never used it. Can't think of when I will. I don't think an Indy movie can be an Indy movie without a collapsing lair, can it?

    ReplyDelete
  2. The movie, Lotr really overdid the collapsing lair thing. I actually used a version of it in my third Futhark book, but it turned out the collapsing lair opened up a new avenue to hell.

    ReplyDelete
  3. *Note to self* Must find a way to collapse my villain's lair.

    *Note to self* Foreshadow the collapse of my villain's lair. Possibilities include mentioning the faulty plumbing of his dark and evil castle or maybe the fact that inept trolls were paid under the table to do the electrical work. Or maybe just sprinkle in bits about the random boxes of dynamite left in the castle dungeon.

    (heh...okay. I should probably get back to the housework. But great post. I've never thought about The Collapsing Lair Trope. Oh, and I'm reading The Lost Hero right now, too. It has one of the best first lines, right?)

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is a trope I seriously don't get. Now I understand if the Hero knocks it down in some epic battle, but the anti-hero self-destruct switch NEVER works. The bumbling evil side kick will be the one to accidentally find it :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved the Mummy! The collapsing liar is a new twist I have never really considered before. Thanks for mentioning it!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Haven't really used this one but then most of my bad guys don't really have lairs built into mountains or tombs.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think every Mummy movie recently had one of those. So did Prince of Persia.
    Closest I've come was the explosion of the ship at the end of CassaStar and Byron trying to get out in time.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The liar collapsing on the villian is also a goodway to leave open the potential for the return of that villian as he actually makes his way to some sort of escape mechanism.

    At which point the villian gets himself a new liar, no doubt on some sort of predatory subprime rate, and is forced into a further life of crime so that they can meet their balloon payment.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have to disagree with Susan. I love it when Barad-Dur collapses.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Deathstar, definitely the deathstar.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I'm a big fan of the collapsing lair. :) LOVE IT.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ripley destroyed the Nostromo in ALIEN right? Also, James Bond did it. A lot. If we move to TV, it happened in both BUFFY and ANGEL; the former when Sunnydale crumbled away in the finale, and the latter when the Wolfram & Hart building in the ANGEL finale. Of course, it happened other times throughout both series. Going further, there's always HALO. And it happens several times throughout the FALLOUT game series.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Oh, and let us never forget pretty much every episode of PHINEAS & FERB.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ah yes there's also Dr Who in the Master and David Tennant episodes. Nice idea I hadn't thought about this plot device.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I love this one. I think I use it a little too often in my just-for-fun-and-no-one-will-ever-read-this writing.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Ever notice how the villain's lair toppling is the signal for the end, but if the hero's pad gets tossed, it always leads to the big rally?

    The Bat Cave has been blown up, Hogwarts was beat to hell, and how long do you think it took them to repair Minas Tirith? (Must have cost an arm and a leg too, what with no more cheep Orc labor to he had...)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Also, I don't know the best, but I can tell you the most irritating: Legend of Zelda. Here you get to the end, kill the bad guy, and you think you are done... then all of a sudden the lair starts to fall, and you have to get out before it crushes you, adding a whole another level to a game you thought you'd finally beaten!

      Kinda lame actually. After emerging victorious from an epic battle in which you ensure the survival of good over evil and save countless lives, getting taken out by a falling rock is a pretty piss-poor way to go.

      Delete
  17. To me the Mummy was a bit too graphic, but that's probably because I was pretty young when I saw it. This is a really nice post!

    www.modernworld4.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  18. I've never used the collapsing lair, but then I've never had a lair. Maybe my bad guys just aren't cool enough.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Well, now I want to use it. Then I want to laugh all evil-like! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hey,

    Happy belated 70th to your Oul' Fella by the way (that's Oirish for Dad, which makes me wonder, why not say "Dad.")

    Anyway, I digress... I meant to say Kudos to your makeover, I know you did this a few weeks ago, but it looks great and so there you go.

    PS. Glad that you showed Indy's escaping, I think that is my fav. collapsing lair.

    PPS... Is it wrong to make your major point in a minor way such as a PS?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Haven't used this yet, but I'll be writing a sequel soon... hmmmm :)

    ReplyDelete
  22. You've got to love the end of Star Wars and the Death Star destruction.
    I haven't written any lairs so far, but there is one in my planned sequel. Now I come to think about it, it would probably ramp up the tension as the try to get out in the nick of time :o)
    You didn't mention whether you've used this yourself.
    Thanks for the inspiration :o)

    ReplyDelete
  23. one of my faves is from treasure planet, love the sci fi in that disney movie spin off!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Collapsing the lair is just. so. handy. Especially when there's all those annoying minions to deal with. Plus, doesn't it look way cooler to run out after you've beat the baddie than to just casually walk out, blinking when you get back in the sunlight?

    ReplyDelete
  25. I love the Tuesday Tropes! Let me think of a scene... Doesn't Saruman's laire colapse in the Lord of the Rings? I can't remember but if it didn't then it definitely should have.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Yup, I definitely use this one! The Mummy example is one of my favorites. So is the scene of Cutler Beckett's death in the third Pirates movie, where he's walking in a daze down the stairs as the ship explodes around him.

    ReplyDelete